Thursday, April 22, 2010

Social Cognitivism Case Study

1. Which teacher in the scenario demonstrates vicarious reinforcement? Justify your response with definitions and an example from the case study.

-Both teachers demonstrate vicarious reinforcement and learning. Mr. K publicly criticizes and berates Robin. Cami and June run up to Robin later just so they can talk about the incident. They even go so far as to say they "hate" him, while his actions were not directed at them. There is now a negative aura accompanying Mr. K, strengthened by the vicarious learning experienced by these girls. Likewise, Mrs. Y publicly praises and even uses Robin's concept map as an example for other students. She holds it up for everyone to see and observe, saying "Why, Robin! This is lovely! Do you mind if I copy it for everyone else? Class, you should see this beautiful concept map that Robin has created." So the other class members are learning by observing the consequences (both desirable and undesirable) of another's actions. We assume that they will adjust their behavior accordingly.

2. Is Mr. Kessinger considering reciprocal causation in his class? Explain your response, including all aspects of reciprocal causation in your reasoning.

-It appears that if he wants a productive, successful experience for his students, then he is not considering reciprocal causation. The environment is now negative, hostile and too risky as evidenced by the vicarious learning of June and Cami. According to the concept of reciprocal causation, this will impact the personal component and behavioral component negatively as well. We can already see that Robin's self-efficacy and other students' personal beliefs are impacted negatively. Her behavior will likely suffer as well; she is already passively sitting in his class with negative feelings, which will breed hostility and possibly acting out. It's amazing the effect one negative "outburst" by a teacher can have on his/her students!

3. Which self-regulated learning process is Robin engaging in when she creates her concept maps? Explain your reasoning.

-Robin is possibly in the Forethought Phase: She is taking notes, planning her own note-taking strategy, her own way of studying, and "testing" it out in class. She is planning and organizing her own learning and performance in her respective classes. She is at a crucial point where she will either decide she can be successful or decide she cannot. While she has experienced some strong outside reinforcements concerning her note/study plan, she herself felt it worked for her own learning style and would help her recall information and learn.

4. How do you think Robin's self-efficacy has been affected by this experience. Be specific about which self-efficacies have been affected and justify your response with examples from the case study.

-By sitting down and actually making a concept map, Robin shows academic self-efficacy. She shows the belief that an investment in her studies will pay off, that it is valuable to her. When Mr. K introduces an aversive stimuli as a presentation punishment to what was such a big part of self-efficacy, it may cause a secondary, more abstract association between her believing in herself and a teacher punishing her. So she may have less motivation to even believe in herself in the first place. Subconsciously, since she feels self-efficacy will be punished, it translates into thoughts and beliefs that negate self-efficacy (in order to avoid punishment.) Mrs. Y will hopefully help positively reinforce Robin's self-efficacy and create a positive relationship between behaviors which demonstrate self-efficacy and teacher praise.

No comments:

Post a Comment