Thursday, April 22, 2010

Behaviorism Case Study

1. Does Mr. Kessinger's class represent a community of learners as defined in Constructivist theory? Why or why not?

No. There is no cooperation between teacher and student concerning knowledge or curriculum. Likewise, Mr K. actually destroyed a potential learning-community-building opportunity. Robin had a lot to share about her own note-taking strategies and learning style, but Mr K. did not want any input or informal suggestion from anyone. He had one way he wanted the class to go and he made it seem like any other way was "bad." He has created a one-way relationship based on fear rather than a two-way relationship based on goals of the classroom community.

2. Does Mr. Kessinger utilize presentation punishment or removal punishment with Robin? Justify your response using definitions and evidence from the case.

Mr. K. uses presentation punishment. He presents Robin with a humiliating and startling reaction to her having brought a concept map to class. Mr. K saw her behavior as undesirable and provided an aversive stimulus. Therefore, she is less likely to ever engage in that behavior, not just in his class, but in others. She cringed as Mrs. Y noticed her concept map about Freud. This is because she had already become conditioned to expect an aversive stimulus to the same behavior.

3. Explain Robin's reaction in Ms. Yamashita's class from the perspective of classical conditioning. Which stimuli are paired and how does that condition her response?

Robin has now learned something by association. Her response was automatic in that she did not think about the fact that Mrs. Y is a completely different teacher and her response could be one of many. (She didn't have a "clean slate" going into her class, she come pre-programmed with a response.)

Unconditioned Stimulus: Mr. K. yells and makes an example of Robin
Unconditioned Response: Robin becomes frightened, anxious, embarrassed and quiet
Neutral Stimulus: Robin creates and brings a concept map to class; teacher sees it
Conditioned stimulus: Robin becomes frightened and anxious when ANY teacher sees her concept map, being conditioned by the frightening and embarrassing effects of the yelling which went along with the first concept map.

4. How might Ms. Yamashita encourage Robin to create concept maps in the future? Include behavioral concepts such as shaping, reinforcement, etc., in your response.

Mrs. Y could use shaping by praising Robin just for beginning a concept map or even talking about doing one again, letting her know that it is a beneficial behavior and that she should feel proud of herself for doing so. She should use continuous reinforcement at the beginning to "cancel out" the aversiveness Robin may now feel towards bringing concept maps to class. It should also be fixed after that for a long time if Mrs. Y wants Robin to continue on in her efforts as Robin will be able to predict and rely on Mrs Y's praise and feedback.

No comments:

Post a Comment