Tuesday, April 27, 2010

FINAL LEARNING LOG, A.K.A. "What the What?"

WHAT?


I scored the highest in "H," or Humanism. My scores were pretty equal in all three categories, which is probably why my highest score was within a combination of both components, Cognitivism and Behaviorism.

Piaget's Cognitive Development


Likes: Chronologically strong; a good starting point for consideration of cognitive levels; establishes basics and benchmarks by which to gauge a child's cognitive level; *The theory of disequalibrium* (like, like, like).

Dislikes: Descriptively general; does not account for environmental influences (or lack of influences); not built to accommodate exceptionalities; rigid; lacking in metacognition; can be imposing (rather than complimentary.)

Vygotsky's Cognitive Development


Likes: Concerns relationship of learning and experience (causational); emphasizes the use of available resources; shows evidence of logical creation (organic); prescriptive rather than purely descriptive; gives "more experienced others" chances to teach and learn as a result; supportive of and driven by cultural specifications.

Dislikes: Somewhat ignores personal, private learning which is just as important as social learning.

Erikson's Psychosocial Development


Likes: Acknowledges our inherent needs; emphasizes need for autonomy and pride in development; helps put a name to the "struggles" of life; seems like it would be a great guide for parents to focus on certain issues at certain ages to increase self-efficacy throughout a lifetime.

Dislikes: Could cause fear due to verbiage, "Those who pass this stage successfully...." (so what is the fate of those who "do not pass this stage successfully?"; does not account for personal, cultural and familial differences; it seems like we could be navigating any of those stages at any age.

Kohlberg's Moral Development


Likes: one of my favorites--easy to identify for the most part if you don't complicate it :); one of the most fascinating of all the theories--clearly examines motivations; could be a great tool for meta-reasoning in and out of the classroom; all stages can be applied to a single scenario, resulting in good applicability (such as the Heinz dilemma.)

Dislikes: misguided in the treatment of a woman's reasoning; could be quite subjective depending on who is evaluating.

Goleman's Emotional Intelligence


Likes: Emphasizes personal responsibility; proactive and positive; a tool for self-regulation and could actually move one up into new levels of moral development with self discipline and the guiding principles of emotional intelligence.

Dislikes: Easier said than done; some people may not care to take the steps needed.

Information Processing


Likes: based in a structural.... structure; easy to grasp; shows learning as process with distinct outcomes (working/ long term memories);

Dislikes: simplistic; humans are not computers and we should remember that the metaphor is simply to help us comprehend what might be happening;


Knowledge Construction and Higher-order thinking

Likes: Clearly defines what a concept is; discovery learning (yay); spiral organization (yay); power in group work; lots of my classes in high school utilized this and I rather liked it; gives students accountability over their own learning yet provides the safety of a learning community.

Dislikes: May leave some students behind as it seems to go at a quick pace; constantly having to come up with an answer, and not being able to, could be bad news for blooming self esteems; it does include the theory of readiness but how can you appeal to each and every student's readiness level?

Behaviorism

Likes: Easy to measure; relatively predictable; introduces an element of "control" on the teachers' part (don't know if that's good or bad...); predictability can provide structure for students who struggle with behavior

Dislikes: it creates a weird relationship between the teacher and the student if implemented too heavily; I still have bad memories from reward systems implemented by my Behavioral Psychologist father. Even though it was mostly reward vs. mostly punishment, still often I felt I was being viewed as a trainable rat; kids catch on to it and it's just weird. In theory and with animals, it's awesome. Humans: weird.


Social Cognitivism

Likes: As Hannah Montana would say, " You get the beeeeeesssssttt of both worlds..."; In a way it takes the weird edge off of behaviorism because it puts much of the control into the student's hands; as a teacher you can rely on vicarious reinforcement and punishment to "effortlessly control the class." Sounds like an infomercial.; ARPM model increases wanted behavior without overt reward.

Dislikes: To be honest I can think of any. I guess the idea of self-regulating is a bit idealistic.

SO WHAT?
My Theory

People learn due to the conflicts, connections and growth happening between personal environment (mind, personal views), social environment and their own biology. At first I imagined my belief being drawn out as a reciprocal cycle similar to the Bandura's Reciprocal Causation model, but the more I think about it, the more I believe a Venn Diagram would better approximate the relationship between the three aspects. There are parts about one aspect that are parts of another. They are not the same thing, but they all contain parts of one another. For example, many parts of social environment become what one views as his or her "personal" environment. I.e., the way one thinks could initially be born out of constant and unintentional modeling of peers and parents. Likewise, one's biology, brain development, chemistry, neurological mapping and obviously genetics, have a direct effect on one's interpretation and acceptance of their social environments, blending together to create a "personal" environment. So, essentially, we are in a large part subject to our own DNA; we ARE our DNA and to think about our DNA is an evolutionary phenomenon which, frankly, scares me. We as humans have evolved way too much....we should stop that.

As far as "how" we learn: it's just that--we think we can control it and get all "meta" on ourselves but we can't truly "control" much. Our body is a lean, mean, learning machine and any way we define it, it's going to happen whether we like it or not. Whether we are kept away from society in a basement and "learn" darkness, noise and basic survival or we are brought up by Nobel Prize-winning parents from Harvard, if all goes as planned by our sneaky little DNA, we are going to adapt to what's in front of us.

So, to think about it that way may seem like taking the easy way out, but I guess I am imposing my beliefs about pure adaptation and evolution on educational psychology. Not that we should treat students as purely gray matter and a brain stem--I believe there is a soul embedded somewhere deep down in our DNA. The point is: drum roll please.....all of these learning theories seem so different but the more I learn about them, the more I think they are basically all describing the same thing, packaged differently and seen from another side.

Wow it's fun to have a theory!

NOW WHAT?

1. My theory, as crazy as it seems on paper, does in fact drive a lot of my ideas about teaching. (I am a tutor right now and have also subbed for a few years, so I am drawing mostly from that.) I believe one can study and study and study their brains out, but if you don't truly believe in what you are implementing as a learning theory, you can end up being a slave to a bunch of facts and definitions rather than a partner with your students. Each theory offers strengths and weaknesses. Luckily we get to pick and choose. For me, the main thing is keeping the "community of learners" alive. This really incorporates the question "What does the student feel?" not just, "How does she learn?" Feelings are inextricably linked to recall and the incorporation of events and information into our memory. If a student in high school can truly feel that he has made an impact on his own learning, that's actually a really big deal. I want to be upfront with my students, careful to keep the classroom from becoming a playing field with winners and losers. Letting them know that learning will take place, in a variety of ways, and that THEY are the biggest influence on their own learning.

2. My next steps will be to read more about assessments. I want a firmer grasp on goals, objectives, standards and outcomes where assessments are concerned. I assume curriculum and content classes will help with this. Our project turned out to be a bit stressful where group dynamics are concerned, so I would like to take a fresh look at assessments and the psychological forces behind them (since you weren't here for that part, I feel like I missed out.) I am also eager to read more about
-Information Processing on a neurological level
and
-Behaviorism on a chemical level

I truly feel like i have gained so much in this class. I have never taken any education classes; as a post-Bac student, most of my English undergrad classes were much more subjective and centered on the honing of skill rather than the learning of new information.

Thanks!

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Social Cognitivism Case Study

1. Which teacher in the scenario demonstrates vicarious reinforcement? Justify your response with definitions and an example from the case study.

-Both teachers demonstrate vicarious reinforcement and learning. Mr. K publicly criticizes and berates Robin. Cami and June run up to Robin later just so they can talk about the incident. They even go so far as to say they "hate" him, while his actions were not directed at them. There is now a negative aura accompanying Mr. K, strengthened by the vicarious learning experienced by these girls. Likewise, Mrs. Y publicly praises and even uses Robin's concept map as an example for other students. She holds it up for everyone to see and observe, saying "Why, Robin! This is lovely! Do you mind if I copy it for everyone else? Class, you should see this beautiful concept map that Robin has created." So the other class members are learning by observing the consequences (both desirable and undesirable) of another's actions. We assume that they will adjust their behavior accordingly.

2. Is Mr. Kessinger considering reciprocal causation in his class? Explain your response, including all aspects of reciprocal causation in your reasoning.

-It appears that if he wants a productive, successful experience for his students, then he is not considering reciprocal causation. The environment is now negative, hostile and too risky as evidenced by the vicarious learning of June and Cami. According to the concept of reciprocal causation, this will impact the personal component and behavioral component negatively as well. We can already see that Robin's self-efficacy and other students' personal beliefs are impacted negatively. Her behavior will likely suffer as well; she is already passively sitting in his class with negative feelings, which will breed hostility and possibly acting out. It's amazing the effect one negative "outburst" by a teacher can have on his/her students!

3. Which self-regulated learning process is Robin engaging in when she creates her concept maps? Explain your reasoning.

-Robin is possibly in the Forethought Phase: She is taking notes, planning her own note-taking strategy, her own way of studying, and "testing" it out in class. She is planning and organizing her own learning and performance in her respective classes. She is at a crucial point where she will either decide she can be successful or decide she cannot. While she has experienced some strong outside reinforcements concerning her note/study plan, she herself felt it worked for her own learning style and would help her recall information and learn.

4. How do you think Robin's self-efficacy has been affected by this experience. Be specific about which self-efficacies have been affected and justify your response with examples from the case study.

-By sitting down and actually making a concept map, Robin shows academic self-efficacy. She shows the belief that an investment in her studies will pay off, that it is valuable to her. When Mr. K introduces an aversive stimuli as a presentation punishment to what was such a big part of self-efficacy, it may cause a secondary, more abstract association between her believing in herself and a teacher punishing her. So she may have less motivation to even believe in herself in the first place. Subconsciously, since she feels self-efficacy will be punished, it translates into thoughts and beliefs that negate self-efficacy (in order to avoid punishment.) Mrs. Y will hopefully help positively reinforce Robin's self-efficacy and create a positive relationship between behaviors which demonstrate self-efficacy and teacher praise.

Behaviorism Case Study

1. Does Mr. Kessinger's class represent a community of learners as defined in Constructivist theory? Why or why not?

No. There is no cooperation between teacher and student concerning knowledge or curriculum. Likewise, Mr K. actually destroyed a potential learning-community-building opportunity. Robin had a lot to share about her own note-taking strategies and learning style, but Mr K. did not want any input or informal suggestion from anyone. He had one way he wanted the class to go and he made it seem like any other way was "bad." He has created a one-way relationship based on fear rather than a two-way relationship based on goals of the classroom community.

2. Does Mr. Kessinger utilize presentation punishment or removal punishment with Robin? Justify your response using definitions and evidence from the case.

Mr. K. uses presentation punishment. He presents Robin with a humiliating and startling reaction to her having brought a concept map to class. Mr. K saw her behavior as undesirable and provided an aversive stimulus. Therefore, she is less likely to ever engage in that behavior, not just in his class, but in others. She cringed as Mrs. Y noticed her concept map about Freud. This is because she had already become conditioned to expect an aversive stimulus to the same behavior.

3. Explain Robin's reaction in Ms. Yamashita's class from the perspective of classical conditioning. Which stimuli are paired and how does that condition her response?

Robin has now learned something by association. Her response was automatic in that she did not think about the fact that Mrs. Y is a completely different teacher and her response could be one of many. (She didn't have a "clean slate" going into her class, she come pre-programmed with a response.)

Unconditioned Stimulus: Mr. K. yells and makes an example of Robin
Unconditioned Response: Robin becomes frightened, anxious, embarrassed and quiet
Neutral Stimulus: Robin creates and brings a concept map to class; teacher sees it
Conditioned stimulus: Robin becomes frightened and anxious when ANY teacher sees her concept map, being conditioned by the frightening and embarrassing effects of the yelling which went along with the first concept map.

4. How might Ms. Yamashita encourage Robin to create concept maps in the future? Include behavioral concepts such as shaping, reinforcement, etc., in your response.

Mrs. Y could use shaping by praising Robin just for beginning a concept map or even talking about doing one again, letting her know that it is a beneficial behavior and that she should feel proud of herself for doing so. She should use continuous reinforcement at the beginning to "cancel out" the aversiveness Robin may now feel towards bringing concept maps to class. It should also be fixed after that for a long time if Mrs. Y wants Robin to continue on in her efforts as Robin will be able to predict and rely on Mrs Y's praise and feedback.

Monday, April 12, 2010

Constructivism and Higher-Order Thinking Case Study Analysis


1. Describe two similarities between the traditional lesson and the constructivist one as described above. What are two differences?

One similarity is that they both concern the measurement of an object. They also both require thinking using ratios. Differences: In the traditional lesson, the teacher provided the how but, it was a very shallow "how," as the students didn't have a concept of a yardstick and that was their primary instrument of measurement. In the constructivist lesson, the teacher did not provide the how, but let their schemas organically lead them to their hypothetical solutions. Also, the traditional lesson already solved the problem of "keeping track of where the ruler ends." The constructivist lesson allowed the students to realize this for themselves.

2. What are two benefits and two drawbacks of the constructivist approach as described above? Why? In your opinion, are the benefits worth the costs? Explain your response.

Benefits: Students will pride themselves on their ability to problem solve and the connections created by doing so will be more likely drawn upon the next time they receive a problem and are asked to find a solution.These connections will also breed more connections, whereas the traditional lesson resulted in very few new connections, just a conclusion of "cool."

Drawbacks: Since incorrect hypotheses are drawn and tried, connections may be made which are related to the incorrect hypotheses, resulting in interference. Also, some students, particularly those with a slower processing time, may not contribute to the solution if others take over and move at a fast pace.

If closely guided, the costs can be worth the benefits almost every time. Stagnation is avoided when students are unconsciously motivated by a play "problem." The skills, rather than the facts, are emphasized in a constructivist lesson plan and therein are the facts naturally embedded. The biology and structure of the brain naturally prepare it for the problem/solution structure that a constructivist lesson offers.


3. How does the constructivist lesson described above promote critical thinking? Give specific examples of critical thinking from the case study and include a definition of critical thinking to support your response.

Critical thinking involves "examining available information and coming up with conclusions based on evidence." The students were provided with the evidence (teacher's suggestions to think about schemas concerning measurement), and were forced to examine it themselves until they discovered a viable answer. This trial and error approach encourages critical thinking by forcing the students to reject unusable hypotheses at the same time as judging them to be so.

4. Would the constructivist activity be considered an authentic activity? Why or why not?

Most definitely. Problem solving is an everyday skill and relating your own schema to a new problem and learning to "try" it out can solve a lot more than memorizing facts out of a book. Strengthening the connections involved in creative and innovative thinking primes the brain to take in new and challenging information, chew on it, spit it out, look at it, and judge it. You can read about how fun a roller coaster is, but if you can't figure out how to get the safety bar down, you can never ride it. Constructivist lessons are like the safety bar, letting us experience and "feel" something in a virtual but impressive way.