WHAT?
I scored the highest in "H," or Humanism. My scores were pretty equal in all three categories, which is probably why my highest score was within a combination of both components, Cognitivism and Behaviorism.
Piaget's Cognitive Development
Likes: Chronologically strong; a good starting point for consideration of cognitive levels; establishes basics and benchmarks by which to gauge a child's cognitive level; *The theory of disequalibrium* (like, like, like).
Dislikes: Descriptively general; does not account for environmental influences (or lack of influences); not built to accommodate exceptionalities; rigid; lacking in metacognition; can be imposing (rather than complimentary.)
Vygotsky's Cognitive Development
Likes: Concerns relationship of learning and experience (causational); emphasizes the use of available resources; shows evidence of logical creation (organic); prescriptive rather than purely descriptive; gives "more experienced others" chances to teach and learn as a result; supportive of and driven by cultural specifications.
Dislikes: Somewhat ignores personal, private learning which is just as important as social learning.
Erikson's Psychosocial Development
Likes: Acknowledges our inherent needs; emphasizes need for autonomy and pride in development; helps put a name to the "struggles" of life; seems like it would be a great guide for parents to focus on certain issues at certain ages to increase self-efficacy throughout a lifetime.
Dislikes: Could cause fear due to verbiage, "Those who pass this stage successfully...." (so what is the fate of those who "do not pass this stage successfully?"; does not account for personal, cultural and familial differences; it seems like we could be navigating any of those stages at any age.
Kohlberg's Moral Development
Likes: one of my favorites--easy to identify for the most part if you don't complicate it :); one of the most fascinating of all the theories--clearly examines motivations; could be a great tool for meta-reasoning in and out of the classroom; all stages can be applied to a single scenario, resulting in good applicability (such as the Heinz dilemma.)
Dislikes: misguided in the treatment of a woman's reasoning; could be quite subjective depending on who is evaluating.
Goleman's Emotional Intelligence
Likes: Emphasizes personal responsibility; proactive and positive; a tool for self-regulation and could actually move one up into new levels of moral development with self discipline and the guiding principles of emotional intelligence.
Dislikes: Easier said than done; some people may not care to take the steps needed.
Information Processing
Likes: based in a structural.... structure; easy to grasp; shows learning as process with distinct outcomes (working/ long term memories);
Dislikes: simplistic; humans are not computers and we should remember that the metaphor is simply to help us comprehend what might be happening;
Knowledge Construction and Higher-order thinking
Likes: Clearly defines what a concept is; discovery learning (yay); spiral organization (yay); power in group work; lots of my classes in high school utilized this and I rather liked it; gives students accountability over their own learning yet provides the safety of a learning community.
Dislikes: May leave some students behind as it seems to go at a quick pace; constantly having to come up with an answer, and not being able to, could be bad news for blooming self esteems; it does include the theory of readiness but how can you appeal to each and every student's readiness level?
Behaviorism
Likes: Easy to measure; relatively predictable; introduces an element of "control" on the teachers' part (don't know if that's good or bad...); predictability can provide structure for students who struggle with behavior
Dislikes: it creates a weird relationship between the teacher and the student if implemented too heavily; I still have bad memories from reward systems implemented by my Behavioral Psychologist father. Even though it was mostly reward vs. mostly punishment, still often I felt I was being viewed as a trainable rat; kids catch on to it and it's just weird. In theory and with animals, it's awesome. Humans: weird.
Social Cognitivism
Likes: As Hannah Montana would say, " You get the beeeeeesssssttt of both worlds..."; In a way it takes the weird edge off of behaviorism because it puts much of the control into the student's hands; as a teacher you can rely on vicarious reinforcement and punishment to "effortlessly control the class." Sounds like an infomercial.; ARPM model increases wanted behavior without overt reward.
Dislikes: To be honest I can think of any. I guess the idea of self-regulating is a bit idealistic.
SO WHAT?
My Theory
People learn due to the conflicts, connections and growth happening between personal environment (mind, personal views), social environment and their own biology. At first I imagined my belief being drawn out as a reciprocal cycle similar to the Bandura's Reciprocal Causation model, but the more I think about it, the more I believe a Venn Diagram would better approximate the relationship between the three aspects. There are parts about one aspect that are parts of another. They are not the same thing, but they all contain parts of one another. For example, many parts of social environment become what one views as his or her "personal" environment. I.e., the way one thinks could initially be born out of constant and unintentional modeling of peers and parents. Likewise, one's biology, brain development, chemistry, neurological mapping and obviously genetics, have a direct effect on one's interpretation and acceptance of their social environments, blending together to create a "personal" environment. So, essentially, we are in a large part subject to our own DNA; we ARE our DNA and to think about our DNA is an evolutionary phenomenon which, frankly, scares me. We as humans have evolved way too much....we should stop that.
As far as "how" we learn: it's just that--we think we can control it and get all "meta" on ourselves but we can't truly "control" much. Our body is a lean, mean, learning machine and any way we define it, it's going to happen whether we like it or not. Whether we are kept away from society in a basement and "learn" darkness, noise and basic survival or we are brought up by Nobel Prize-winning parents from Harvard, if all goes as planned by our sneaky little DNA, we are going to adapt to what's in front of us.
So, to think about it that way may seem like taking the easy way out, but I guess I am imposing my beliefs about pure adaptation and evolution on educational psychology. Not that we should treat students as purely gray matter and a brain stem--I believe there is a soul embedded somewhere deep down in our DNA. The point is: drum roll please.....all of these learning theories seem so different but the more I learn about them, the more I think they are basically all describing the same thing, packaged differently and seen from another side.
Wow it's fun to have a theory!
NOW WHAT?
1. My theory, as crazy as it seems on paper, does in fact drive a lot of my ideas about teaching. (I am a tutor right now and have also subbed for a few years, so I am drawing mostly from that.) I believe one can study and study and study their brains out, but if you don't truly believe in what you are implementing as a learning theory, you can end up being a slave to a bunch of facts and definitions rather than a partner with your students. Each theory offers strengths and weaknesses. Luckily we get to pick and choose. For me, the main thing is keeping the "community of learners" alive. This really incorporates the question "What does the student feel?" not just, "How does she learn?" Feelings are inextricably linked to recall and the incorporation of events and information into our memory. If a student in high school can truly feel that he has made an impact on his own learning, that's actually a really big deal. I want to be upfront with my students, careful to keep the classroom from becoming a playing field with winners and losers. Letting them know that learning will take place, in a variety of ways, and that THEY are the biggest influence on their own learning.
2. My next steps will be to read more about assessments. I want a firmer grasp on goals, objectives, standards and outcomes where assessments are concerned. I assume curriculum and content classes will help with this. Our project turned out to be a bit stressful where group dynamics are concerned, so I would like to take a fresh look at assessments and the psychological forces behind them (since you weren't here for that part, I feel like I missed out.) I am also eager to read more about
-Information Processing on a neurological level
and
-Behaviorism on a chemical level
I truly feel like i have gained so much in this class. I have never taken any education classes; as a post-Bac student, most of my English undergrad classes were much more subjective and centered on the honing of skill rather than the learning of new information.
Thanks!