Sunday, March 14, 2010

Case Study

Cognitive Development (Ch. 3) Analysis Questions:

1. From the perspective of Piaget's theory, in which stage of cognitive development is Laura? Justify your response.

-Though I don't have more information about Laura, this single case study shows a high level of egocentrism in Laura's mind, which may place her in the preoperational stage. She sees her teacher as unreasonable when she poses any other perspectives and misses the point of debate, which is to see issues from all possible sides. The limiting factor of Piaget's theories is that, while Laura seems to be stuck on egocentrism, I'm sure if you performed conservation and seriation experiments, she would show to be in or past the pre-operational stage. She may be missing some propositional logic but likely can navigate other kinds of logic present even in the formal operational stage.

2. How is Laura's reasoning affected by her knowledge base--that is, by what she does and doesn't know about pollution? Use terminology from Ch. 3 in your response.

-She uses the reasoning that scientists could "just" come up with a chemical that would be strong enough to dissolve garbage but gentle enough not to pollute to support her idea of totally banning the sale of gasoline, but she doesn't realize that if scientists could "just" come up with something like that, then they would have already invented a non-polluting fuel. Since her schema includes little about science and pollution, this seems reasonable to her.

3. By posing a series of questions, Mr. Marculescu continually challenges Laura to reconsider her thinking about the pollution problem. What are potential benefits of this strategy? Use terminology from Piaget's and Vygotsky's theories in your response.

-By constantly putting Laura in a state of disequalibrium, Laura can practice going through the stages of cognitive conflict, accommodation and equilibrium. And if she sticks with debate, she can strengthen those processes, thereby building a higher-order schema.

4. How does this scenario represent Piaget's and Vygotsky's conceptions of play?

-For Laura, her pretend play (Piaget) occurs when she uses her arguments about pollution as symbols for her broader understanding of science and. Her Schema is challenged to grow as different scenarios and questions are posed. Things she may have formerly rejected or ignored are playfully pricking her cognition, leading to eventual assimilation. Vygotsky's theory supports the use of social interaction, through the teacher's interactive questioning, to challenge Laura's schema. According to Vygotsky, it is the modeling and interaction itself which grows the cognition.

Social and Moral Development (Ch. 4) Analysis Questions:

1. From a social development standpoint, how might we explain Laura's preoccupation with her appearance? In particular, consider this statement by Laura: "I don't want people to think I'm a geek!" Include information from Erikson's theory and social development in general in your response.

-Laura is in the Identity vs. Role Confusion psychosocial stage. She feels her whole identity will be cemented by her being seen one time without her hair and makeup perfect. She also feels her identity lies in what is being visually shown to others about her. She feels very vulnerable about being "caught" appearing a certain way and consequently receiving a negative label.

2. In suggesting that Laura join the debating class, Ms. Watkins is hoping to pique an interest in classroom subject matter by capitalizing on Laura's desire to be the center of attention. What two other strategies might the school faculty use to motivate students who seem to be more interested in social matters than in academic pursuits?

-Use role-play to untilze prior, stronger schemas of social interaction as frameworks for learning; monitor patterns of friendship to be aware of those who are super-social, possibly pairing them with someone who needs their influence (maybe even privately letting them know they are of value and influence to this person ahead of time.)

3. From the perspective of Kohlberg's theory, in which stage of moral development is Laura? Justify your response. How might Mr. Marcalescu help Laura to advance her moral reasoning?

-Laura is possibly in or approaching Stage 4: Law and Order. Her ideas about pollution are interesting and quite grandiose, but her motivation comes from a feeling about helping society as a whole. She could have said that no one should do anything about the pollution and that people shouldn't have to change their lives to help others. Even though her logic is flawed, morally she "gets" that people need to pitch in for the sake of community.

4. In what ways might a debating class contribute to students' cognitive, linguistic, social, and moral development?

-Debate is a great place for students to playfully pose hypothetical viewpoints, challenge them, and have them challenged. Cognitively, this is prescriptive for assimilation of new knowledge, helpful for those who may still be stuck on egocentrism, and gives opportunity for cognitive development through social interaction and patterning. It is also a perfect laboratory for the development of language by requiring quick answers, verbal organization and providing modeling. Socially and morally, students can rub off on each other in a way parents and teachers can't. Having their ideas accepted by their peers (and practicing having them not accepted) may help resolve intimacy vs. isolation and the subtle nuances in individual thinking, schema and belief can enrich differentiation.

No comments:

Post a Comment